Your spot to relax
Experience Old Town Mexican Cafe
Old Town Mexican Cafe is a delightful gem located in Key West, offering a genuine taste of Mexico with every dish. Renowned for its fresh and authentic flavors, the cafe features a diverse menu catering to all palates, including delicious vegetarian options. Signature dishes like tortilla soup and flavorful tacos, paired with vibrant house margaritas, consistently impress diners. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, along with attentive staff, enhances the dining experience. Whether enjoying a lively happy hour or a leisurely meal in the charming outdoor garden, Old Town Mexican Cafe captures the essence of Mexican cuisine, making it a must-visit destination in the Keys.
Taste the best
Discover Menu
Queso Fundido
Chicken Machaka
Jalapeno Margarita
Pomegranate Margarita
Discover More
Old Town Mexican Cafe
Welcome to Old Town Mexican Cafe, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Key West, where vibrant flavors and authentic Mexican cuisine await you. This cozy cafe captures the essence of Mexico, offering a delightful dining experience that transports you straight to the heart of Mexican gastronomic culture.
Upon stepping into Old Town Mexican Cafe, you're enveloped in a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family. Guests consistently rave about their experiences here, highlighting everything from the superb tortilla soup to the mouthwatering beef burritos smothered in rich red sauce. One customer mentioned, "It tastes like a little Mexico here in the keys," which perfectly encapsulates the authentic dining experience provided by the cafe.
Vegetarians will find a haven of delicious options, as noted by one delighted guest, who enjoyed a variety of flavor-packed dishes. Flavourful nachos and tasty enchiladas showcase the cafe's commitment to fresh ingredients and authentic recipes, ensuring everyone finds something to love.
Don't miss out on the cafe's renowned street tacos, celebrated for their freshness and bold flavors. As per one review, "Great Street Tacos! Best salsa!" The only drawback? A second bowl of salsa incurs a charge—an indication of just how popular these dishes are!
For those seeking a leisurely experience, the outdoor garden seating offers a relaxed vibe complemented by friendly and attentive staff. Guests can take advantage of the Happy Hour, which features half-price appetizers like calamari and nachos, alongside refreshing house margaritas that provide the perfect accompaniment to your meal.
Whether you're sampling the Mahi Mahi tacos or indulging in the flavorful steak tacos, each bite at Old Town Mexican Cafe promises to be a celebration of taste and tradition. It's no wonder that visitors express their eagerness to return, with one customer stating, "It was hard to beat." So, if you find yourself in Key West, don’t miss this incredible destination that has quickly won the hearts (and stomachs) of locals and tourists alike.
For any inquiries, you can reach Old Town Mexican Cafe at +1 305-296-7500.
Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ One of the best Mexican restaurants I’ve been. The food is fresh. It taste like a little Mexico here in the keys. We had the tortilla soup and the beef burrito with red sauce. Really good ”
“ I visited this lovely Mexican café in Key West, and it turned out to be a good food experiences during the trip! As a vegetarian, I was delighted to find so many delicious options — from flavourful nachos to tasty enchiladas and several other vegetarian dishes. Everything was fresh, authentic, and full of flavour. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the staff were friendly and attentive. If you’re visiting the Southernmost Point of the USA, I highly recommend stopping by this café. A perfect spot for anyone looking for great Mexican food with plenty of vegetarian choices! ”
“ Great Street Tacos! Best salsa! They will charge you for 2nd bowl of salsa. Plus, you get to eat with chicken. ”
“ Had dinner here. It was outside, and they had fans, but I would add more. It was SO HOT out. The food was pretty good and so were our margaritas. ”
“ Our first dinner in Key West and it was hard to beat. My wife got the Mahi Mahi tacos and I got the Steak tacos, and let me tell you, they were amazing. 1 bite and I was sold. Can't wait to go back! ”